Black PR vs. Black PR?

By Sean at 7 February, 2010, 11:03 pm

As the Power Vertical’s Robert Coalson explains, this is the way the game is played.  Anyone familiar with Russian politics over the last 20 years, if not the last century, will not be surprised United Russia hatchet-men hired “spin doctors” to spread black PR against opponents of UR power broker and Saratov deputy Vyacheslav Volodin.  I’m impressed that their smear arsenal included such creative tactics such as hiring a student to throw animal shit at journalists and paying homeless to stage rallies in support of opposing candidates.  I’m sure if someone digs deep enough they will probably find a few Nashists on the payroll.

The revelations come from Sergei Pochechuyev and Igor Osovin, who have detailed their service as political hit-men in their soon to be published book, The Black PR Practitioners Of The White Bear (Chernye piarshchiki belogo medvedia).  The two authors, who write for the aptly named Conspirology.org, claim that in 2007 alone they managed a 2 million ruble black PR cash box to smear whoever they were ordered to smear.  Last Thursday, on Volodin’s birthday in fact, the two broke ranks and held a samokritika and promotional, er, “sensational” press-conference where they confessed their sins.  To beef up the accusations, as well as their confessions, the conference was accompanied by flowcharts and graphs showing the connections between Pochecheuyev and Osovin and their alleged employer, UR Duma deputy and Volodin right-hand man Nikolai Pankov.  They also presented documents detailing the expenses for their nefarious black PR plans.

According to Coalson and a report on the duo in the Moscow Times, Pochecheuyev and Osovin have come forward out of a “crisis of conscience about their work.”  Yeah, because, like that happens.

Nikolai Pankov quickly responded that the accusations were “absurd” and called Pochecheuyev and Osovin “provocateurs.”  He promises to see piarshchiki in court.

Given that as Coalson correctly states this is how the Russian political game is played, shouldn’t we ask whether this latest revelation is black PR about black PR?  The question is apt considering that in politics in general, and in Russian politics in particular, the devils always outnumber the saints, and the latter usually don’t appear out of nowhere, and certainly not out of some “crisis of conscience.” Don’t get me wrong, I don’t doubt Pochecheuyev and Osovin’s claims for one millisecond.  I’m just suspicious of their sudden conversion to the politically righteous. Even the possibility they are just currying fanfare to sell books doesn’t cut it.  The Russian politico-conspiro-tell-all book market just isn’t large enough.

My guess is that someone somewhere has decided that Volodin and Pankov need to be taken down or at least humbled a bit.  Perhaps some of the local potentates are sick of getting screwed and have decided to do some of the screwing.  Maybe someone is aiming a scope at Volodin from above waiting to blow a hole is his fontanelle.  Who knows?  But I do know one thing, so far this story smells exactly like the black PR the two authors claim to be known for.  And given how anti-corruption is now all the rage, what a better way make a good show than to beat Volodin and Pankov with their own sticks.  As for whether this is really the case, we’ll have to be patient.  If this scandal fades away, then we can conclude that Pochecheuyev and Osovin are really the latest versions of St. Augustine.  If the scandal sticks, then that will suggest that something more sinister is afoot.

Russian elites continue to cannibalize themselves.  Don’tcha love it?  I know I do.

Popularity: 1% [?]

Categories : Corruption | Russian Politics | Scandal | United Russia

Comments
Robert Harneis February 8, 2010

Sounds like Karl Rove’s been at it to me.

Gleb Tsipursky February 8, 2010

Good analysis, Sean

Pyotr February 8, 2010

Robert Coalson is thoroughly confused. “Opposition” (somehow I think by this he does not mean KPRF, JR or LDPR) is not popular because of their rigidity and lack of the new ideas that lead to their marginalization and not because of the specific political tactics used by everyone, be that white or black PR. Note how in his piece Robert himself engages in black PR against Putin.

As for this specific case of black PR, indeed, it looks targeted specifically against Volodin and Pankov, but you have to keep in mind that Pochecheuyev and co, based on their site, are seasoned political operators and their press conference can be part of much bigger scheme.

Yes, “crisis of conscience” argument does not wash. Those guys have 15-20 years in political consulting and them protesting against black PR is the same as bees staging protest against honey. Speaking about corruption: check out CVs at their site and note how their journalistic/political consulting jobs positions overlap.

I don’t see “cannibalization”, either, just regional politics that spilled over to the federal newspaper.

Aleks February 9, 2010

I go with Andy’s ‘rebranding exercise’ for future growth opportunities though I don’t really see how it could in any way be more sinister rather than just more of the same. Did this two finely tuned political animals really smell something different in the air, jumped first (at least you get to chose), we’re pushed or maybe, as another possibility, were coopted to signal to all their other colleagues that the game is changing so come aboard or face the consequences?

Hopefully the latter as a sign that a real clean up is in effect and phase II of rebuilding Russia has started.

BTW, speaking of black PR, spin and stuff, has anyone watched the British TV series ‘The Thick of It’ ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_thick_of_it )? A film with the main PR supremo called ‘In the Loop’ was shown recently at Sundance ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_the_Loop_%28film%29 ) which is ‘a satirical version of events surrounding the run-up to the 2003 invasion of Iraq’.

Jesse February 10, 2010

And of course, there is always the classic flying phallus – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dq_-Gf9rXhE

Sean February 10, 2010

I forgot all about that! The flying cock is the best. I wonder if I could craft my own.

mr. mike February 17, 2010

All you need is an r/c helicopter and a block of foam. Measure the chopper out, draw a dick on the block of foam, and get carving. Hollow out a space for the chopper frame in the foam dick and remember to cut holes for the main rotor and the stabilizer (if necessary.) Paint the dick whatever skin tone you like, and you should have an obscene flying object which will annoy flatheads for miles around.

Leave a comment

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree

Spam protection by WP Captcha-Free