Last year I was in a Moscow taxi riding from Sheremetevo to my apartment at Profsoiuznaia after spending Christmas in Germany. Of course I began talking to the driver, asking questions about himself, and his family. He happily told me that he had four sons. As a joke I told him that he was raising an army. To this day I don’t know if it was my bad Russian or that my mention of the word “army” brought him such immediate and undeniable disgust. “I wouldn’t send one of my sons to the damn army. I won’t let them take not a one.” I then explained to him what I meant by the comment. He replied, “Not an army, a football team!”
The near death beating of Private Sychyov by an officer at the Chelyabinsk Armor Academy is just another example of why Russian parents like my taxi driver will do anything to get their sons out of the draft. Articles on the incident call Sychyov’s beating, which resulted in the amputation of his legs and genitals because they developed a gangrenous infection, as “hazing” or dedovshchina. I’ve dealt with dedovshchina elsewhere. But the English word “hazing” doesn’t fully capture the violence and brutality of this incident. This was not some fraternity prank. This was not some simple initiation ritual. “Hazing” just doesn’t do it. This is just pure violence.
Here is how former Russian Army Colonel Viktor Litovkin describes the incident on Russia Profile:
Military prosecutors are still investigating the details, but what we do already know is that that a number of drunken “older” enlisted men and NCOs, led by Corporal Alexander Sivyakov, spent several hours tormenting Sychyov, who had only joined the Logistics Battalion at the Chelyabinsk Tank Military College two days earlier. He was forced to crouch for with his arms stretched out in front of him for an extended period, and was then tied tightly to a stool. There have been reports – unsubstantiated as of yet – that the 19 year old soldier was also raped.
The result was severe swelling of Sychyov’s legs, the death of some of the muscle and, ultimately, gangrene. He turned to military doctors for help only four days after the attack, and then only because he was unable to get out of bed. The doctors not only failed to diagnose his condition properly, they failed to treat him at all. Sychyov ultimately had to call the emergency service of a municipal hospital where, in order to save his life, doctors were forced to amputate both of his legs, his genitalia and one finger. He remains in a critical condition, with no guarantees from the doctors that he will survive.
I wanted to write something more substantive on this incident. Time just doesn’t permit me. I urge readers to continue reading Litovkin’s commentary.

Great posting. I only barely touched on this incident myself and referred to another blog (Neeka’s Backlog) for text and photos.
I worry that too many Russians might feel that, as Americans, we don’t have a right to criticize incidents like this in the Russian military. It certainly leads to some very defensive remarks. I’ve seen some comments from Russians claiming that suicide rates in the Russian Military are no worse than those in the US Military, for example.
However, I think dedovshchina undermines the credibility and fighting ability of the Russian military. I also think it is important to US strategic interests that Russia maintains a credible and capable army.
It is amazing to me that the Russian government and army have been so unwilling to deal with these incidents. It seems to me easy enough to correct, both in the short-term and long-term. Court martials for guilty parties, and weeding out of NCOs and officers that allow such behavior to continue. Long-term the Russian military needs to perhaps become smaller, pay better, and move towards a volunteer force. Eventually if you restore pride and honor back to the Army, individuals can see it as a realistic career choice, and you can encourage a larger army. But as it stands now, the Russian army is run like the Louisana prison in “Cool Hand Luke”.
I came across an online journal that has devoted an entire issue on hazing. You can find it here: http://www.pipss.org/sommaire190.html.
By the way, something I miss in all the discussions about hazing is the point of view of the perpetrators. I am getting really curious about how they feel about torturing other people; whether they have any remorse, or how they look back on the dedovshchina after leaving the army; whether, after leaving the army, they change their opinions on the dedovshchina in general and on their own actions in particular.
Such voices are hard to come by. I don’t know the reasons why. But you can get a sense of them from the report Human Rights Watch did on dedovshchina. I included some of it on an ealier post on dedovshchina
Thanks, Sean!